Touch wood

Sorry I haven't been around much lately. I've been taking a long holiday after all the difficulties of the last year or so. I'm back in the UK now, though, and what should catch my eye but a new season of Torchwood.
Maybe you remember how critical I've been of that particular franchise in the past. I may even have blamed it for some of the worst television I've seen in my whole life. Which you might think would make me avoid it, but I don't. There are two reasons for this. One is the only sign of possible patriotism I've yet detected within myself. If the UK is exporting television to the world, I'd rather it wasn't howlingly wretched. Or maybe I just want Britain to have a thriving TV industry so that one day there'll be room for me in it. And the other reason is somewhat similar: if I ever end up selling a script to a TV production company, the chances are that shows like Torchwood will be my competition. And if that competition is puerile drivel, that's worth knowing. So with my fish-rifle in hand, I pulled up another barrel of Torchwood and prepared to open fire.
I knew they'd made changes, I'd heard there was a new direction but nothing could have prepared me for the sensation I experienced while watching ep1 of season 3: the feeling of mild enjoyment. Even excitement in places. And amusement. (And only the very infrequent twinge of major irritation.) Is it possible they've changed Torchwood so much that it's actually... good?
Maybe you remember what my biggest complaint was with Torchwood season one? The team were supposed to keep Earth safe and all they did was imperil it, while whining and bickering. Earth would be markedly safer if the Torchwood team were disarmed and locked in a Big Brother house somewhere, squabbling among themselves.
Season two saw the team occasionally tackle problems instead of just causing them. They still moped and whinged constantly - and don't forget the bickering. And they were still the least impressive front-line against alien malevolence you could imagine. But despite shooting themselves in the foot at every opportunity they sort of almost sometimes saved the day. Nearly.
But something strange has happened now that season three is here. A crisis has presented itself and what remains of the team are attempting to resolve it in a professional and even insightful manner. And then, when the chips are down and disaster strikes, they are somehow keeping it together and making intelligent, capable efforts towards remedying the situation. They still have emotions and weaknesses, but somehow these things no longer prevent them from doing their jobs - even excelling at them. Curious.
I know this is going to be hard to believe, but I really didn't want episode two to end. I wanted more. More! - not less.
It's still not what you might call 'superb'. But neither is it a blot on the TV schedules and a waste of licence-payers' money. And what's more, I'm enjoying it.
It can't last, of course. Soon, the team will decide that expressing their inner anguish takes precedence over the survival of the human race. Or they'll get into a big argument and start shooting each other (as they are so wont to do). But just for now, I'm really enjoying this little oasis of acceptable quality television - and tentatively hoping it might last a week or two longer.
(Remember, you can watch BBC programmes that you've missed using iPlayer. And you can even download programmes to watch offline if you use a bit of software like get_iplayer. It's not the friendliest thing to use, but if you wanted to grab a quicktime copy of s3ep2 of Torchwood, you'd type:
get_iplayer Torchwood
then you'd note that the show you wanted was numbered 697 so you'd type:
get_iplayer --get 697
and the file will start downloading.)
Comments: 4
Welcome back Rob. I was knocked sideways by Children of Earth, after the perpetual disappointment of previous seasons. I wittered at length over on my blog (probably with spoilers, beware), but it was the best bit of Brit Sci-Fi I've seen in years.
Posted by: Richard Wright on July 25, 2009 11:49 AM
I enjoyed it - hadn't laughed so much in ages. Especially enjoyed the shot of Capt. Jack's backside.
Posted by: NaomiM on July 26, 2009 12:10 AM
Hi Rob - I hope the break has helped and been enjoyable.
I didn't even watch the second series of "Torchwood." I thought the first series was a bit of joke - Dr Who with themes of an Adult(?) nature - Not.
But I thoroughly enjoyed "Children of Earth."
It had its flaws and was cheesy in parts, but it had most of the components a serial should have - it hooked me and kept me wanting to know what would happen next. Bringing in the families of the main characters added a little bit of depth, and there were some adult themes (if you listened between the lines)in the form of moral dilemmas - How come you earthlings make such a fuss about your kids when you let millions of them die every year from malnutrition and treatable diseases?
"Torchwood" (IMO)also felt like an attempt to challenge the almost inevitable demise of drama on TV. It flew in the face of - "We don't do drama any more because it's expensive and audiences are declining - Just give them more of the same - quiz shows, celebrities doing things and homes and gardens." It was trying something new (or even possibly old)- drama that people watched live so they could talk about it in work the following day.
Perhaps I've over-stated the case, but I don't really want to spend my dotage flicking between 50 channels all showing re-runs of "Minder" and "Friends" or some smug git being helped to locate an ideal investment property in Magaluf.
Anyway - welcome back.
Posted by: Paul on July 26, 2009 08:54 AM
Good to have you back, Rob.
I enjoyed it too, and I love how many times Russell D gets men snogging into the script ;) (It was Russell D wasn't it?)
Posted by: Fiona Robyn on July 27, 2009 10:17 AM