Computers. [Hur.] What are they good for? Absolutely...

posted by Emma on October 27, 2007 09:16 PM

ORAC

The solution?

... nothing when it comes to proofreading.

Answer me this, linguistics fans. (That'll be you then, Rob. We really should find some other way of communicating rather than via this blog. If only there were some sort of cable-based system where individual handsets, incorporating both a speaker and microphone, could be allocated a number, and if entered on an associated keypad the handsets could connect to each other? Maybe in the fantastical, far-off future. But I digress.) Is written language so blinking complicated that a computer can't be told all its rules? I thought not. So why do I still have to spend 48 hours proofreading a book manually?

Surely - surely - there must be a program somewhere that automatically flags up things like missing punctuation, capitalised letters where they shouldn't be, inverted commas the wrong way round, hyphens where en dashes should be, doubled up words, words that shouldn't be next to each other and so on?

I should really get on with my Java coursework, then write an application to do it. It can't be that hard.


spacer

Comments: 2


If you've ever tried Word's automated grammar check, you'll know why a computer can't proofread. *grin* I will never voluntarily write 'wanna' or 'gotta'.

Apart from then, obviously.


Your headset idea is interesting and I'd like to subscribe to your newsletter. But on the subject of this grammar program...I think it's because computers can't judge appropriateness. Sometimes "ain't" is justified; comma splices work in dialogue sentences where they don't in narrative sentences; sometimes you gotta wanna break the rules. Computers don't think that way. Rules are rules.

spacer

Post a comment

We love hearing from our readers, but please stay relevant and pleasant. The comments are for responding to the specific blog post above. If you have any other queries, please contact Snowbooks via email. Off-topic or offensive comments will be removed without notice.

To screen out automated spam, please answer the following very easy question:

What colour is nice, new snow?

(please use all lower-case characters for your answer; no capitals)


Back to the blog »